Stanford has announced that Meyer Library is going to be ripped down "by 2012."
I noticed that nowhere in that Stanford Daily article do they name the architect of the building, the "Internationalist" John Carl Warnecke, who is also responsible for the Stanford Bookstore, the Stanford Post Office, and (farther afield) the truly weird AT&T Long Lines Building, a apocalyptic and windowless skyscraper designed to "protect the valuable equipment within." It looks like something you'd see looming in the background of a Terminator movie. I don't know much more about that building, but I wonder what's in it today. Who has the corner office in that building, I wonder?
Back to Meyer Library. From the Stanford Daily article:
* * *
"Meyer Library is essentially doomed," said Andrew Herkovic, director of communications and development of libraries. "The building has not aged very gracefully, it needs millions of dollars worth of seismic upgrades and it's not cost-effective to keep it in the long term. It's also, in my opinion, an eyesore."
A second reason for the library's demolition is its violation of previous plans for campus layout.
"The original campus master plan wanted that area to be a corridor, not a building," Herkovic said. "Today it is very much in the way of traffic, and it also stands out oddly as a building larger than those around it. Architecturally, that's considered a defect."
* * *
In this way earlier painstaking debates about Stanford architecture are swept away.
I don't really like the building, either, and I'm glad to see it go, I guess, but it makes me wonder whether it's worth thinking about architecture at all in a serious way. Particularly on university campuses, all it takes is a few administrators to throw out the word "architecturally" and "violation," and that's it.
Yet there are some buildings is hard to imagine Stanford ever blowing away. The Quad, for example, and maybe Hoover Tower. Everything else could easily get ripped down I think. They're doing it already, in a big way, on the west campus.